Mom’s night out

by Anti-Racist Parent Columnist Jae Ran Kim, originally published at Harlow’s Monkey

My family lives in a neighborhood in the city that is very diverse; many of our neighbors are Hispanic Latino, Somali and African American. Our kids go to a public school that has a Montessori core curriculum and because of that there is less diversity in the school as there is represented in my neighborhood; the school has become a magnet for liberal, white hippie parents who want to enroll their kids in a Montessori school.

Two weeks ago, I found out that one of my co-workers also has kids at this school, and her son is the same age and grade as my son. She asked me if I knew about the “Mom’s Night Out.”

This past year, it seems that several women decided it would be fun to host a “Mom’s Night Out” for mothers whose kids attend our school. It is an appetizer and cocktail potluck hosted at different mother’s homes. The next “Mom’s Night Out” was scheduled for the same evening as the school’s spring choir concert. Since I hadn’t heard of the event, my co-worker said she’d send me the on-line invitation and put me on the e-mail list.

So the morning of choir concert, my husband and I show up 15 minutes early. Greeting us is Mary, a parent volunteer and, I find out, the host of the “Mom’s Night Out.” I know this factoid because after giving every parent a program for the concert, she asks the women if they are a mom and if the answer is yes, hands her a printed invitation for the “Mom’s Night Out” and explains that it’s being hosted at her home that night.

Every woman except me, that is. With me, she hands me the program and tells me where I can sit. No invitation to the “Mom’s Night Out,” even though it’s right there in her hand and I just saw her give it to the couple in front of me, and as I watch while sitting down, she gives it to the woman behind me. Then, with some time to spare, she goes around and gives them out to women she might have missed coming in. Still, she never approaches me.

So you can see where I’m going here. For fifteen minutes, I wait for Mary to approach me and she doesn’t. Yet, every white mom gets an invitation. I watch Mary walk around the audience, handing out invitations. None of the moms of color get one.

My husband and I are sitting next to my son’s best friend’s parents and I ask Kate whether she knows about the “Mom’s Night Out.”

“You mean the cocktail party?” she asks me. “Oh yeah, they’re so much fun!”

I looked around at the number of Muslim parents who are in the audience. None of those moms would come because of the alcohol being served. It was pretty obvious to me that this party was, by purpose or by omission, exclusive and I didn’t look “right” enough to be invited by Mary.

I’m sure Mary didn’t intentionally exclude me, or all the other moms of color, or Muslim moms from this event. Likely, Mary isn’t even aware of her biases that unconsciously steered her away from moms like me, making her uncomfortable. Mary can’t be excused from being “shy” as I observed her approach unfamiliar women all around me. It was a blatant act of being excluded because of my race. Mary must not interact with many people of color.

On Monday, when I get to work, I will ask my co-worker how the “Mom’s Night Out” was, and ask her if any moms of color attended. I will tell her what my experience was and why I chose not to attend. Since my co-worker is friends with several of these moms, I know she will pass on my concerns. There are probably several who will be upset because they think of themselves as allies with communities of color. These are the white folks who live in the city, and think of themselves as politically and socially progressive.

Well, as long as they get to choose who is invited to their parties.

Jae Ran Kim, MSW is a social worker, teacher and writer. She was born in Taegu, South Korea and was adopted to Minnesota in 1971. She has written numerous articles and essays and is most recently published in the anthology “Outsiders Within: Writings on Transracial Adoption” from South End Press. Jae Ran’s blog, Harlow’s Monkey, is at http://harlowmonkey.typepad.com/

Share and Enjoy:
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • del.icio.us
  • Current
  • email
  • Google Bookmarks
  • NewsVine
  • Ping.fm
  • RSS
  • StumbleUpon

Trackbacks & Pings

  1. Antiracist Black Family Seeks Antiracist White Families for Friendship, Camaraderie and Fun (race unimportant) at Anti-Racist Parent - for parents committed to raising children with an anti-racist outlook on 13 Jun 2007 at 7:02 am

    [...] (mixed), we could easily find ourselves in a similar situation to what fellow ARP columnist Jae Ran Kim recently mentioned a place where parents of white children are happy to have their kids learning alongside students of [...]

Comments

  1. shelli wrote:

    I’m AGOG. Which city did this happen in?

    Wow. Sadly, I’m faced DAILY with looks, stares, and comments. I think the more subtle art, if you will, would hurt more, in fact.

    But then again, I’m the type that would have gone up to Mary myself and said – “oh, I’m a mom, too, can I have an invite?” Just to watch her blush…

  2. Gunfighter wrote:

    I would love to say tha I was shocked by this… but I’m not.

    Recently, a woman that goes to my church and coaches soccer with me, told me about a cocktail party held for the ladies in the church. The ladies, many of whom we know, were having a great time together, when the subjecy of attractive TV stars came up… when it was her turn, D said that she thought Eriq LaSalle was sexy. Apparently it was so shocking to everyone that they all went silent. They even had the nerve to ask her if she was serious… as if it was impossible for this white woman from the Virginia suburbs to believe a black man could be found attractive.

    Oh, by the way, my wife is apparently guilty by association (I’m black) and wasn’t invited.

  3. mamazilla wrote:

    jae ran, i’m so sorry this happened to you… your experience reminds me of my own chicago neighborhood and a similar experience that i had. i can say from this one experience, maybe it’s good you didn’t go. i wish i hadn’t.

    a caucasian mom neighbor of mine invited me to a moms night out that she was invited to. she was new to the neighborhood like me and didn’t know anyone. so, we went and virtually no one talked to me. she was constantly introduced and involved in conversations. but i couldn’t get anyone to talk to me. belive me i tried. i’m not even sure they thought i could speak english. it was so uncomfortable. i’m not sure why i stayed to the bitter end. i was so glad when it was over.

  4. landismom wrote:

    I wish I was surprised by this, but I can’t say that I am. Over the past three years, my daughter has been attending a school that is about 50% white kids and 50% children of color. I can’t tell you the number of parents of color who have commented to me that I am the only white mom who talks to them. And like you point out, it’s not that the other white moms are shy–they will go up to a new white mom and say hi to her, introduce themselves, etc. But they are unconsciously avoiding all of the women (and men, for that matter) of color.

  5. Jae Ran wrote:

    This experience was just the latest in a long string of experiences that are similar. While I don’t really feel any hurt over the slight in a personally emotional way, I’m so tired and ticked that it keeps happening so blatantly.

    Back when I was a stay at home mom, I tried to get involved in a “Mom’s Group” and despite trying for weeks by volunteering to be part of committees (where I’d never get a call from the organizer) or playgroups (where all the moms would hover together and ignore me) I finally gave up.

    I’ve done all the things people have suggested both on line and off, in the past. I’ve invited myself, I’ve made the efforts to “give it time” and I’ve volunteered to be on committees or what not. This time, I observed the interactions and waited just to see if my hunch would be right. And it was.

    I’m not sorry that I didn’t go to this party, I”m angry that I wasn’t invited like all the other white moms.

  6. Vera L wrote:

    This sounds so familiar. Only, at my school, it was an email group started to discuss curriculum issues in a particular class. White parents were included in the email group — not even very involved and active parents of color (like me) were invited into the discussion. One of the moms who has a clue cc’d me midway through the exchange with a “you might be interested in this”, and when I joined the email chain I got a “We’re so glad you’ve joined us!” response that sounded utterly insincere by that point. There was absolutely no effort made by the group as a whole to hold this discussion (the goal of which, by the way, was to communicate with the principal about the classroom issues) to involve a broad range of parents. These are the same parents who wonder why parents of color “just don’t come to meetings.”

  7. Meera Bowman-Johnson wrote:

    I’m so sorry you had that experience, I understand how you feel. In an integrated school, you’d hope that *all* of the parents have their kids there because they want to give them an opportunity to flourish in an integrated environment and make friends with kids of other backgrounds. Unfortunately, many parents like the idea of an integrated school *in theory*, but the reality of actually socializing beyond the paramaters of what’s most familiar or “comfortable” to them is much too scary. Even the ones who think they’re progressive.

  8. Jessalyn Anglin wrote:

    Wow! It looks like she needs a copy of Beyond the Golden Rule

  9. turtlebella wrote:

    You live in Minnesota, right? I know because as racially and ethnically diverse as my neighborhood (all that you mentioned, plus lots of Hmong folks) is in St Paul, the white people here are the most clueless people I’ve ever met, in terms of their own racism and biases. It’s like they are in denial that they live in the same city with people from different cultures and of different races. And your experience directly relates to my fears for the future. My husband and I deliberately chose our neighbohood because there is lots of diversity- racial, ethnic, socioeconomic. As a multi-ethnic family we want our kids to not have to live in an all white all middle class enclave- it just seems like such a place is really skewed and weird to us. And we’ve considered sending them to the montessori public school because we like the educational philosophy. BUT we wonder if going to such a school- which seem to be all the rage among white upper middle class people- will just be so completely contradictory to the values we want them to grow up with.

  10. Kim wrote:

    Jae Ran, I’m a little confused about the passage which follows, and the way I am reading it – as an unconscious, though less-than-benign oversight on the part of the host/host, Mary.

    “I’m sure Mary didn’t intentionally exclude me, or all the other moms of color, or Muslim moms from this event. Likely, Mary isn’t even aware of her biases that unconsciously steered her away from moms like me, making her uncomfortable. Mary can’t be excused from being ’shy’ as I observed her approach unfamiliar women all around me. It was a blatant act of being excluded because of my race. Mary must not interact with many people of color.”

    Where you begin with her actions sounding possibly unintentional, you build a case for something stronger by way of a race-and-color -based bias which she then acts upon.

    What am I not reading right, please?

    (I’m sure you “can’t get to the clothes in your closet/’cause a sorry”*…and yet my spirit aches to know that you underwent such an experience.)

    * From Ntozake Shange’s ‘For Colored Girls Who Have Considered Suicide/When the Rainbo is Enuf

  11. JaeRan wrote:

    Kim, you bring up a good point and what I’ve learned since this happened (a few weeks ago, now) is that I began like a lot of people do, and I was looking to give Mary the benefit of the doubt that it wasn’t intentional. But even as I continued writing, you can see that I am not fully believing my own self here.

    In real life and when posted on my blog, a few have commented and asked why I was sure it wasn’t intentional. And again, my answer is, I’m not sure. In fact the more I look at it, the more I think it was intentional. But I don’t think it was conscious, I think Mary was acting on her own unacknowledged prejudices.

    What is equally as telling about this incident is that every mom of color who I’ve related this story to has right away said it was intentional and asked me why I was giving Mary the benefit of the doubt.

    turtlebella, I used to live in St Paul and my kids went to a Montessori school there too. Probably the same one you’re talking about, if it’s the public school. And actually I found the neighborhoods were worse in terms of racism and bias than where I live in Minneapolis now — but the school was better. I can’t quite figure that one out. I’d happily switch school districts and keep my neighborhood if I could.

  12. Dawn wrote:

    Sorry this happened to you. It is all too familiar. Our neighbors who have not spoken to us twice in the last 5 years asked when we were going to introduce our son to the other kids on the street. I’m thinking why, so you can ostracize him too? No thanks.

  13. Frances wrote:

    I, too, am not surprised by your experience. I am Caucasian, my ex-partner is African-American, and my two adopted children are African-American. I and my family have experienced exclusion and/or discrimination almost on a daily basis, and it has come at the hands of of people that are every color of the rainbow and political spectrum. We’ve been excluded from black parents’ groups, white parents’ groups, Latina mothers’ groups, various church groups, et al. I’ve become pretty adept at discerning whether or not I’m the victim of racism or just blissful ignorance. Sadly, I have found my circle of friends has morphed into a circle of acquaintances, and I have very few people that I can speak with regarding this topic.

    Jae, I hope that you have better luck than I have had when I have discussed matters of race with my co-wokers, whom I considered to be my friends. Don’t be surprised if your friends don’t quite ‘ carry the torch’ for you in your attempts to be a part of these groups. Generally, I’ve found that until a person is involved somehow with a person of another race, they have no clue that racism is so prevalent in today’s society, and when confronted by that accusation, they deny it, and pretty much accuse you of being ultra-sensitive.

    Good luck!

  14. Dorothy wrote:

    What a horrible experience. I’m really sorry that happened to you. Regardless of whether Mary’s action was intentional or subconscious, it made you feel bad, so it she should apologize. I think letting your co-worker know how you felt is the right thing to do – she needs to get the message now, before she teaches her kids to act the same way.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared.